-
Fady Khalla started the topic Regression Verification and Validation in the forum The Design History File 8 years, 8 months ago
As we all have learned this week from Dr. Simon, If any of the Verification or Validation test cases have failed during the V&V processes, the specifications have to be either reviewed or changed and these tests have to be repeated. From my experience, sometimes a regression test is sufficient to test the changed specifications. In other cases,…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Combination Products in EU in the forum EU Regulatory Basics 8 years, 8 months ago
Hi All,
As we all know, the US FDA handles Combination products according to their Primary Mode of Action (PMOA). For example, If the device PMOA is through chemical interaction, its approval process is handled through Center of Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER). In EU, the term combination product does not exist. Products are either considered…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Guidance Documents in the forum EU Regulatory Basics 8 years, 8 months ago
Hi Andrew,
I have always used Guidance documents to get better clarification on what the regulation is actually looking for. More specifically, I have used multiple MEDDEV guidance documents to make sure that I am following the right path when I am somewhat lost about what should be done. Guidance documents contain non binding roles. As Dr. Simon…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Discussion Topic: Easier regulatory in EU? in the forum EU Regulatory Basics 8 years, 8 months ago
Hi all,
From my limited experience, it is indeed a lot easier to obtain EU approval prior to US approval. The main reason in my opinion is that in EU the manufacturer is not dealing directly with the regulatory agency. The manufacturer is dealing with a notified body which is contracted to review the on behalf of the EU competent authority. There…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Multi-Center Clinical Studies in the forum Introduction to Advanced Medical Device Development 8 years, 8 months ago
As we all have learned from Dr. Simon’s lecture this week. There are multiple types of clinical studies, including:
1- prospective
2- retrospective
3- Blinded
4- Randomized
5- placebo controlled
6- Multi-CenterThere are many advantages of doing a clinical study with any of the methods mentioned above. The multi-center clinical studies looks like…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Primary Mode of Action (PMOA) in the forum Introduction to Advanced Medical Device Development 8 years, 8 months ago
As we all know, The definition of the Combination product is ” a product comprised of
any combination of a drug and a device; a device and a biological product; a biological product
and a drug; or a drug, a device, and a biological product. Under § 3.2(e), a combination product
includes:
1. A product comprised of two or more regulated components,…[Read more] -
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Discussion Topic: Your Field or Profession in the forum Introduction to Advanced Medical Device Development 8 years, 8 months ago
Hi All,
I have to agree with most of you regarding 3D printed medical devices becoming a popular trend. I currently work in a pharmaceutical company handling design controls and Risk management activities for their combination products. I see that many companies now are working hard to reveal the many possibilities that 3D printing brings to the…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Written Agreement v/s Verbal Agreement in the forum Consultants and Legal Basics 8 years, 10 months ago
From a legal standpoint, a written agreement is far more better than an oral one. As others have mentioned, a written agreement can be easily defended in court and can solve disputes quickly. with an Oral agreement, you get into the grey area of I said and he said. Which are not easy to solve. Therefore, I have usually believed that a written…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Restrictions for physician's gifts in the forum Consultants and Legal Basics 8 years, 10 months ago
Hello Roberto,
The gift restrictions are established by the Sunshine Act that came into effect in 2010. I had to personally abide by the restrictions of the Sunshine Act before. We were conducting a clinical study at one of the hospitals. when the study was completed with successful results. The company thought that inviting the Physicians and…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Consultants NDAs and CDAs in the forum Consultants and Legal Basics 8 years, 10 months ago
Hello Everyone,
we all learned this week about NDAs and CDAs. After working with consultants for about 3 years. I realized that some of them do not bind by the NDAs or the CDAs they sign. From my experience, We hired a consultant who was helping my company establish design controls for our company. After working with the consultant we found that…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Discussion Topic: Your organizational type in the forum Organizational Development in Device Companies 8 years, 10 months ago
As I have mentioned in a different post. I work in a hybrid organization that utilizes Functional and Matrix organization. This hybrid type uses project managers within departments. There is no specific team responsible for project management. Coming from a small startup company that basically did not have any organizational structure to a company…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Organization Type vs. Effectiveness in the forum Organizational Development in Device Companies 8 years, 10 months ago
As we all have learned from this Week’s videos, each organization structure has its own pros and cons. Each company is structured in a certain way to allow for full utilization of all available resources. I have worked in different companies that utilize different organizational structures. I have worked in a small company where organization…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Forming a Project Team in the forum Organizational Development in Device Companies 8 years, 10 months ago
I believe that all the responses above have mentioned what are the best practices to form a good project team. from my personal experience. Most of the time, you do not get the chance to pick your team members or even your project (especially if you are a project manager). In a functional organization, the Project manager goes to each department…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic how far is "As Far As Possible" in the forum Risk Analysis for Medical Devices 8 years, 10 months ago
The ISO 14971:2012 “Risk management for medical devices” requires manufacturers to reduce risk As Far As Possible without any economical consideration. I consider this a huge Conundrum for all medical device manufacturers. It is a gray area where lots of questions float around. The regulation is clear. it states As Far As Possible(AFAP). What is…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Risk Identification in the forum Risk Analysis for Medical Devices 8 years, 10 months ago
I believe that all the responses here are very valuable and they offer very good methodologies on how risks are identified. From my experience, Risk identification starts from the intended use, intended users and use environment. Once all these have been defined for a certain device, risk identification process can start. The process starts with…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Usability Risk Analysis in the forum Risk Analysis for Medical Devices 8 years, 10 months ago
As we all know, A major step of risk management is risk assessment and identification. Recently, usability has been a hot topic for risk management. Most Regulatory agencies around the world would ask for the company strategy to mitigate risks arising from use issues. Some manufacturers utilize and Application FMECA to address use issues. Other…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic Combination Product Phase I clinical Studies in the forum Introduction to Design Controls 8 years, 10 months ago
Combination products have been controversial topic since the introduction of 21 CFR part 4 in 2013. Combination products can consist of Drug & Device, Biologic & Device, or drug/Biologic. Most Drug and Biologic products requires Clinical trials that are divided into phase I, Phase IIa, Phase IIb and Phase III. During phase I clinical studies, the…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Minutes for meetings in the forum Introduction to Design Controls 8 years, 10 months ago
Good discussion so far everyone. As everyone have mentioned, Meeting minutes is considered to be a very important tool to track project progress and keep everyone on track. From my experience, if you conduct a lot of meetings (especially virtual meetings such as WebEx, Skype, etc.) people tend to multitask during these meetings. This might lead to…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla started the topic When is validation is not required? in the forum Introduction to Design Controls 8 years, 10 months ago
As we all have learned this week, a validation may not be required if:
– There were no changes required to the product after verification.
– A clinical trial is not required
– Product changes did not affect the user interfaceFrom my experience, the human factors study is considered a part of the design validation. So if no changes were required…[Read more]
-
Fady Khalla replied to the topic Design input sources in the forum Introduction to Design Controls 8 years, 11 months ago
Design inputs do not only include physical and performance characteristics of the device. Design inputs should also include functional requirements, safety requirements, applicable regulatory requirements and -where applicable- information from previous similar designs. I have seen many companies struggle with what to include in their design…[Read more]
- Load More