Yes, a smaller startup can benefit from efficiently using design controls. The advantage can start as early as the design planning and scope management phases. A smaller startup may be more likely to ...

I wanted to add that the way design controls are perceived also goes a long way. A lot of tension is generated, I think, when design controls are viewed simply as a regulatory burden rather than a way...

Ideally, you’d imagine companies doing both. They need to fulfill regulatory requirements for the sake of remaining compliant, but they must strive to uphold product quality to maintain or improve the...

I believe that you make a great point that the constant updating of the documents contents can become very confusing or lead to an overload of information as you say. The most important thing to do in...

That’s a great point — keeping “living documents” like the DDP continuously updated is essential, but it can easily become overwhelming if not managed well. One effective approach organizations use is...

This is a really good point about the updating process of living documents within the medical device process. I think organizations can balance maintaining up-to-date documentation while preventing in...

In reference to the title of the question, I do not think that there should necessarily a winner in regards to whether user needs or engineering viability are more important. The teams should instead ...

I think the best way to balance user needs with business limits is to acknowledge that both sides are part of the design problem. In class, we have gone over how the design begins with user needs but ...

In practice, successful design teams balance user needs and business realities through structured trade-offs rather than choosing one side completely. Engineers should advocate strongly for essential ...

To me, balancing the user needs alongside business goals seems like a hard challenge to accomplish, although also an important part of the development process. From any viewpoint, the ideal position i...

I am in agreement with what everyone has said so far, especially regarding the points about how collaboration and regulatory boundaries are imperative. I also like the emphasis on how pre-planning can...

Engineers should "fight" for an ideal design in a way which describes their design as a benefit to the business. In design, usually user needs will complement business goals. For example, designing a ...

I think this is a great question to consider since it is something that most of us, as engineers will eventually face. What is more important, user needs or the business limitations/needs. I think, in...

Another perspective to consider is how regulatory and ethical obligations can affect the balance between user needs and business constraints. In other industries, such as consumer technology, compromi...

That’s a great question—and one that every real-world engineering team faces. In practice, it’s all about finding a balance between user-centered design and business feasibility. Engineers should abso...