Forum

Dev Doshi
@dev-doshi
Trusted Member
Joined: Sep 5, 2025
Last seen: Nov 30, 2025
Topics: 7 / Replies: 34
Reply
RE: Old Style Consulting & How Far It Went

The AdvaMed and DOJ oversight has become so strict since scandals have become large-scale and public. One example is the 2007 orthopedic device kickba...

3 days ago
Reply
RE: How “Modest” Should Gifts to Physicians Really Be?

I think the real issue with defining what “modest” means is about how the gifts to the physicians are functioning on a psychological level. Something ...

3 days ago
Reply
RE: When Does a “Consulting Agreement” Become a Red Flag?

I agree with what everyone has said so far. However, I think red flags can appear before you even look at the deliverables or compensation. The compan...

3 days ago
Reply
RE: Design Controls vs Project Management — Why Do We Keep Mixing Them Up?

I think a key issue in integrating Design Controls and Project Management is the lack of continuous feedback loops between the two. The distinction be...

1 week ago
Reply
RE: When and How Should Engineers Speak Up to Leadership?

I agree with the points raised by everyone so far. Addressing concerns to someone higher up is very daunting since relationships are at stake and you ...

1 week ago
Reply
RE: The Office Drama Nobody Asked For

  I agree with what everyone has said so far. Another way to make a matrix organization is to build predictability into the workflow, along wit...

2 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Distinguishing Between Hazards and Hazardous Situations in Risk Evaluation

I think everyone here did a good job at breaking down the conceptual difference between hazards and hazardous situations. Something new I have to add ...

3 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Getting Everyone's Input in Risk Management Meetings

I like how everyone emphasized how important structure, preparation, and inclusion is in risk management meetings. I want to talk more about the forma...

3 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Poka-Yoke/ Error Proofing

Everyone has brought up excellent points about Poka-Yoke and how it reduces errors on the production floor. However, something that no one has touched...

3 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Efficiency or Compliance?

I agree that design controls are more than a regulatory requirement in the sense that they are frameworks for quality and long-term communication. To ...

4 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Process Validation for OEMs

I think everyone made great points regarding documentation, calibration, and clear communication between the Original Equipment Manufacturers and the ...

4 weeks ago
Reply
RE: Can Verification Cause a Tragedy?

I agree that the Therac-25 incident changed how we think about design controls; however, I think that the next "Therac moment” might come from overcon...

4 weeks ago
Reply
RE: User Needs vs. Business Goals — Who Wins in Design?

I am in agreement with what everyone has said so far, especially regarding the points about how collaboration and regulatory boundaries are imperative...

1 month ago
Reply
RE: Verification vs. Validation — Do We Really Need Both?

I agree that verification and validation have distinct purposes that keep the design controls objective and therefore reliable. Verification makes sur...

1 month ago
Reply
RE: Design Transfers to Contract Manufacturers

I liked the point regarding maintaining consistent QC and QA in transferring design control. I also agree that there is great importance in maintainin...

1 month ago
Page 1 / 3